Ninth Circuit invalidates “regulatory departure bar”

by | Jul 1, 2015 | Firm News |

Last month, the Ninth Circuit held in Toor v. Lynch that a noncitizen can still move to reopen or reconsider his or her removal proceedings after departing the United States voluntarily while the proceedings are still pending.

Previous to this decision, whether a noncitizen was still permitted to file a motion to reopen or reconsider after departing the United States voluntarily was in question. The Federal Regulations at sections 1003.23(b)(1) and 1003.2(d) prohibited it directly (called the “regulatory departure bar”), yet the subsequent federal statute under the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRIRA) allowed one to file a motion to reopen/reconsider after departing the United States without specifying when and how the departure was made.

The Ninth Circuit now clarifies that the IIRIRA does supersede the regulatory departure bar, allowing those who have voluntarily departed the United States during their removal proceedings to move to reopen or reconsider their cases.

This is very good news for individuals who were ordered removed for “abandoning” their immigration cases by departing the United States. Although you may now be able to move to reopen or reconsider the removal order, a motion to reopen/reconsider must still be timely and conform to very specific rules. It is a good idea to contact an immigration attorney if you have any questions.

Bean, Lloyd, Mukherji, & Taylor is an immigration law office in Oakland, California emphasizing family-based immigration, citizenship, removal defense and deferred action.

Follow us on Twitter @beanlloydllp


Big News- Firm Merger!

Bean + Lloyd, LLP and Park & Taylor to form Bean, Lloyd, Mukherji, & Taylor, LLP

We are thrilled to announce the merger of Bean + Lloyd, LLP and Park & Taylor, two highly respected Bay Area immigration law firms, beginning April 16, 2021. The new firm, Bean, Lloyd, Mukherji, & Taylor, LLP, combines decades of immigration experience in the subfields of family-based immigration, removal defense, asylum, humanitarian visas, and criminal immigration.

Partners Jesse Lloyd and Anita Mukherji, both certified specialists in immigration and nationality law by the California State Bar, will lead the firm. Karyn Taylor will join as Of Counsel, and Angela Bean will remain as partner and Anna von Herrmann as Of Counsel. The Park & Taylor staff will bring their two decades of experience to the team.

Bean, Lloyd, Mukherji, & Taylor, LLP, will maintain both its Oakland and San Francisco offices. While both offices will be temporarily closed to the public due to COVID-19, our staff will still be available by phone, email, and text message, and all consultations and client appointments will continue by phone or video. We look forward to reopening physically when it is safe to do so.

Please contact us at (510) 433-1900 or with any inquiries.

You have Successfully Subscribed!